Family
Why I Only Wear Black — Even in Summer
I love to go noir whether it's hot or cold.
You might think that an older person like me might want to brighten up my wardrobe to be more visible in the world, to have my happy personality reflected in what I wear. You might think that as summer turns sultry, I’d reach for pastels or whites to reflect the heat.
That’s where you’d be wrong.
I’ve been dressing in black since I was a teenager. I admit, at first it was a rebellion against the shockingly bright clothing my mom bought me, from a blindingly yellow corduroy dress (my friends called me Traffic Light) to the neon pink bridesmaid dress I was forced to wear to my sister’s wedding. This dress was as decidedly wrong for me as I knew the groom was for my beloved sister.
In college, I entered the dark side even more, finally buying all my own clothing, and most of it was, you guessed it, black, as oppositional to the bright colors I had worn. Black made me feel sophisticated, important for an 18-year-old. I was mysterious, I was strange in the best of ways. I was finally my own person.
“Isn’t it boring? Don’t you want a color that really sings?” some friends asked. To me, black is absolutely operatic in its voice. “Don’t you want to experiment with color?” other people nudged. I do experiment, but with black, because black has shades of meaning, from the beatnik noirs of my late teens to the punk obsession with the dark side when I moved to Manhattan.
This extends right up to what I wear now, which are usually simply structured pieces with something of a little twist, like a black satin pocket on a black sweater, or the wide fluid legs of black velvet jeans. My blacks can be jet propelled or popped with a line of white. I’m too busy to fuss with colors that grab onto sauce or wine like magnets. I’m too interested in life to have to worry about what goes with what and what doesn’t.
Black always does, and I’ve found nothing more satisfying than mixing up the shades of the newest noir with the old classics I already own.
Wearing all black is a statement that can make me stand out even more than go-signal green. I refused to wear white to my wedding and instead wore midnight blue, which is really a softer name for black. “How will people know you’re the bride?” my aghast mother-in-law asked, and I happily pointed out if they didn’t know maybe they shouldn’t have been invited.
My pregnancy wardrobe? I bought out all the black Eileen Fisher clothes, which were cut larger than I was. A jumper, a jacket, a few shirts. As a proud mama, I bought some black clothing for our son, too, because what I wanted for him was to start strong, distinct and creative.
“Wearing all black means you want to vanish,” some critics tell me, but it’s actually just the opposite. Especially now that I am older, when supposedly women vanish. (I don’t believe that.) If I wanted to vanish, I wouldn’t encourage my wild, long mop of dark hair (bottle-black, of course). If I wanted not to be noticed, I wouldn’t pay attention to the cut and drape and style of my noir necessities.
To me, black shows emotional depth and mystery. Minimalism is always stronger than maximalism.
I’ve also been told I wear all black because I must be depressed and black clothing would only make me more so, that a brighter color might mean a brighter mood. Black is indeed the color of mourning, but not everywhere.
In India, it’s white. In other cultures, it’s red. When my husband and I first moved to Hoboken, New Jersey, the older Italian widows were swathed in that fiery shade. And I’m not mourning or unhappy. Instead, I’m exhilarated wearing black, because it grounds me. It makes me feel capable and unafraid of anything, the way any piece of favorite clothing might feel to any person wearing it.
Do I ever not wear black? Sometimes, I will wear chocolate brown, sometimes a splash of red, but I always am faithful to my favorite shade. Like capital letters, black draws attention. It asserts itself. Last week I bought a deep blue shirt and had to take it off after an hour because I was too aware it wasn’t me. What I really want is for the clothes to be loyal, always dependable in making me feel fabulous, defined and defiantly myself.
Oh yes, of course I want to live a colorful, exciting life. But I want to be the person wearing only black while I’m doing it. And this summer, this beach babe’s got it made in her favorite shade, too. I am about to hit the beach in a sheer black cover-up and matching flip-flops, because black goes with everything — especially me.
More From The Ethel
More for you, from AARP
We are a community from AARP. Discover more ways AARP can help you live well, navigate life, save money — and protect older Americans on issues that matter.